Showing posts with label religious capital. Show all posts
Showing posts with label religious capital. Show all posts

Monday, January 5, 2026

Understanding Why Some People Stay in Their Religion While Others Leave

The following is a blog post written with the assistance of the Econ 17 Chatbot. I uploaded a printed pdf copy of this recent Religion News Service article and asked the chatbot to write a blog post that used the concept of religious capital to help us understand the patterns in the research study. I gave the chatbot some specific instructions in my prompt to provide it with clear direction on what I wanted. I then made edits and revisions to get the final product. I could have used the Pew report as the source, but I chose to use the news article because of its newsy style of writing.

----------

A recent article from Religion News Service explores findings from a new Pew Research Center report on why some Americans stay in their religion while others leave. The study, based on data from Pew's 2023-24 U.S. Religious Landscape Study surveying 8,937 adults, reveals that childhood religious experiences are the primary factor determining whether Americans maintain their faith into adulthood. While 56% of Americans still identify with their childhood faith, 35% have switched religious affiliations—including 20% who now claim no religion. The data shows a stark difference: 84% of those with positive childhood religious experiences remained in the same faith as adults, compared to 69% of those with negative experiences who now identify as having no religion.

From an economics of religion perspective, this phenomenon is not just about faith; it's about deeply ingrained social processes and accumulated investments that create powerful incentives to stay.

One key concept that helps us understand religious persistence is cultural transmission. Think of it like passing down a family recipe—parents and communities transmit religious beliefs, practices, and values to the next generation through repeated exposure, direct teaching, and social feedback. This isn't always a conscious process for the recipient; it's often absorbed through upbringing, social networks, and early experiences.

The article's findings that people with positive childhood religious experiences are more likely to remain in their faith provides clear evidence of cultural transmission at work. When cultural transmission is successful, individuals develop strong preferences for their inherited religious tradition. Conversely, negative childhood experiences represent failed or costly cultural transmission, making individuals more likely to seek alternatives or abandon religion altogether.

The concept of religious capital—the accumulated benefits and resources derived from religious participation—also applies. Religious capital includes social networks within the religious community, knowledge of traditions and practices, emotional connections to rituals, and the sense of identity that comes from group membership. Like any form of capital, religious capital results from investment that has been built up over time.

When individuals have invested significant time and effort into building religious capital within their current tradition, the economic cost of abandoning it becomes substantial. They risk losing not only their established social connections and support systems but also the familiar framework for meaning-making they've developed. The benefits of staying within a familiar religious tradition often outweigh the perceived benefits of seeking alternatives, especially when the costs of acquiring new religious capital in a different tradition are high.

This economic framework helps explain why 84% of people with positive childhood religious experiences stay in their tradition, while 69% of those with negative experiences leave. Positive childhood experiences represent successful cultural transmission and early investment in religious capital, creating strong incentives to remain. Negative experiences suggest failed transmission and lower accumulated religious capital, reducing the switching costs of leaving.

Understanding these economic forces can help religious communities better support positive cultural transmission and recognize that religious commitment often reflects rational responses to the costs and benefits of participation, accumulated over a lifetime of experiences and relationships. Human beings, it turns out, are remarkably good at making decisions that maximize their well-being—even in matters of faith.

Wednesday, September 3, 2025

Understanding Religious Decline Using the Concept of Religious Capital

The following is a blog post written with the assistance of the Econ 17 ClassChat chatbot. I uploaded a copy of the Pew Research Center piece and asked the chatbot to write a blog post that used the concept of religious capital to help us understand the patterns in the research study. I then made several edits and revisions to get the final product.

-------------

Headlines about declining religious affiliation worldwide might seem to tell a straightforward story of secularization. However, applying economic analysis—particularly the concept of religious capital—reveals a far more nuanced picture of what's actually happening to religion around the globe.

We see this in a recent piece published by the Pew Research Center. This piece summarizes a recent academic research article that describes how religious decline follows a predictable three-stage pattern called the "Participation-Importance-Belonging" (P-I-B) sequence. First, people participate in worship services less frequently. Second, the importance of religion diminishes in their personal lives. Finally, formal religious belonging becomes less common. This pattern appears across 94 countries and territories studied, suggesting a universal mechanism of religious change.

Religious capital a key concept from economics of religion, refers to the accumulated knowledge, skills, social connections, and cultural familiarity that individuals develop through participation in religious activities. Like financial capital or human capital, religious capital is built through investment (time, effort, participation) and can depreciate without maintenance.

When we view the Pew Research Center's findings through this economic lens, the three-stage decline pattern makes perfect economic sense. People first reduce their investment in building religious capital by attending services less frequently. As their religious capital depreciates, religion becomes less important in their personal lives. Finally, formal religious belonging becomes less valuable as their accumulated religious capital diminishes.

The economic framework helps explain why religious decline isn't universal. In regions like Western Europe and parts of the Americas, several economic factors may be reducing the returns to religious capital investment. Increased opportunity costs mean that as secular alternatives become more attractive and accessible—better entertainment, social services, education—the opportunity cost of time spent in religious activities rises. Government crowd-out occurs when governments provide social safety nets, healthcare, and community services that religious groups traditionally offered, reducing the practical benefits of religious participation. Reduced network effects happen in societies where fewer people participate in religion, decreasing the social benefits of religious capital and creating a self-reinforcing cycle of decline.

Conversely, regions maintaining high religiosity—like parts of Africa, the Middle East, and South Asia—often have economic conditions that maintain high returns to religious capital. Religious groups continue to provide essential social services, strong social networks make religious capital more valuable, economic insecurity increases demand for the insurance and support functions religion provides, and government restrictions may actually increase the value of religious identity and community.

Understanding religious decline through an economic lens suggests that simple demographic projections may miss important dynamics. If the economic returns to religious capital change—through shifts in government policy, social conditions, or the competitive landscape—religious participation patterns could shift more rapidly than linear projections suggest.

The global pattern of religious change isn't simply about belief or cultural evolution—it's also about changing economic incentives. Where religious capital provides valuable returns through social networks, services, meaning, and community, religion thrives. Where secular alternatives provide better returns on time and effort invested, religious participation declines.

This economic perspective doesn't diminish the spiritual or cultural significance of religion, but it does help us understand why religious change follows predictable patterns and why one-size-fits-all predictions about secularization often fail. As the global economy continues to evolve, so too will the economic landscape that shapes individual decisions about religious participation and the accumulation of religious capital.

Friday, August 23, 2024

Inviting Someone to Church

How religious beliefs and preferences form is an important question in the academic and scientific study of religion. In this class we have talked about several ways to think about the formation of beliefs and preferences, and one of the most prominent is cultural transmission that occurs along multiple dimensions. You are most familiar with vertical transmission (parent-to-child), but for many religious groups horizontal transmission (peer-to-peer) is just as important or even more important.

One way to study horizontal transmission is to measure how often people invite someone to attend a religious meeting with them. A recent article in Christianity today discusses one study of American Protestants propensity to invite others to church.

According to this study, about 60% of American Protestants who attend church have invited at least one person to attend with them during the six months prior to the survey. About 20% made two invitations during that time, and 20% also made three or more invitations.

Read the article to learn who are the people most likely to extend invitations, how the extending of invitations varies across age groups, and more.

These invitations generate create potential for a lot of horizontal cultural transmission! Of course, not all invitations are accepted, so this is very much a numbers game. The larger the number of invitations extended, the larger the number of invitations accepted even if the percentage of acceptances is low. This is all the more reason why a religious group that wants to grow should encourage its members to extend invitations.

Wednesday, August 7, 2024

Religion and the Allocation of Time in America

Every year the U.S. Census Bureau conducts a national survey, called the American Time Use Survey, in which they collect data on how people spend their time throughout the day. It is an important survey for researchers in economics and other social sciences because its unique data allows them to study a large variety of research questions.

The most recent Time Use Survey (2023) reveals some interesting facts. For example, on average Americans spend:

  • 9.84 hours/day on personal care and sleep.
  • 1.20 hours/day and drinking.
  • 1.92 hours/day doing household activities.
  • 0.66 hours/day shopping.

You can see some summary charts here, but more better details are in some published tables here. It is there that you can get specific information about time spent in religious activities.

The civilian population 15 years and older spend, on average, about 0.11 hours/day on "religious activities." That is about 6.6 minutes per day. About 60% of that time is spent "attending religious services," and the other 40% is spent "participating in religious practices."

The average time spent on religious activities per day is higher for women (0.14 hours) than men (0.09 hours), which is consistent with the standard finding that women are more religious than men in the U.S.

Though of course there is some variance across people with some spending a lot of time and others spending no time on religious activities. For those who participate in religious activities, the average amount of time spent in religious activities is 1.50 hours/day.

Here's a table with a few comparisons:

Activity

Avg hrs/day,

entire population

Avg hrs/day,

participants only

Religious and spiritual activities

0.11

1.50

Volunteering

0.10

2.11

Socializing and communicating

0.57

1.96

Relaxing and leisure

4.00

(TV= 2.67)

4.51

(TV = 3.62)

Sports, exercise, and recreation

0.34

1.57

Telephone (calls, mail, email)

0.16

0.90

On the surface, the numbers for religious and spiritual activities seem small compared to the other non-work, not-sleep categories in the table. But keep in mind that a lot volunteering may be religiously-motivated or organized through religious groups, some time spent socializing or playing sports may be with members of one's congregation, and communication may also be with other religious group members. So even if time spent on direct religious practice seems small, there are many activities that have a religious dimension even if not labelled as such in the survey.

Nonetheless, there are a lot of activities that vie for people's limited time, and religious groups are always competing not just with other religious groups but also the many other non-religious "distractions" in life. In fact, it might be the little decisions about religion that people face every day that really determine the value and impact of religion in their lives.

Here are some questions for you to think about:

  • Which non-religious activities pose the largest threats to religious activities?
  • How do you think the cost and benefits of these non-religious activities has changed in recent years?
  • How do you think the answer to the above question might depend on your age?

Tuesday, April 9, 2024

Religion and Happiness

Empirical results from social-scientific data analysis are always under scrutiny, but there is one pattern that is so well established that it appears to be beyond dispute. That pattern is the strong and robust positive relationship between religion and happiness. A recent article in the Deseret News provides a very accessible summary of some of the findings.

Read this article, and as you read you should ask yourself a variety of questions.

  • Why are religious people happier?
  • Is there a causal relationship between religion and happiness so that religion actually makes people happier?
  • Are all religious people happy? Why or why not?
  • If religion does make people happier, then does mean that religion is overall good for society?

Tuesday, October 25, 2022

The Religious Value of Trunk or Treats

 A "trunk or treat" is a Halloween activity held in a parking lot or large open field in which adults decorate their automobile trunks with Halloween decorations and hand out candy to children who walk from car to car in their Halloween costumes.

This article at RNS discusses how churches have become suppliers of trunk or treats.  Read the entire article and ask yourself why churches have become suppliers of trunk or treats.  Who attends the trunk or treat?  Why can a trunk or treats be an effective religious activity?  What religious purposes can a trunk or treat serve?

Tuesday, October 11, 2022

The Costs and Benefits for Different Kinds of Religiosity

Chapter 4.2 of the book of the text discusses the relative importance or "nature" and "nurture."  According to studies, both nature and nurture influence religiosity, but the relative importance of each differs by the type of religiosity.  In particular, religious affiliation tends to be more stable and influenced by one's parents throughout one's life than church attendance.

Consider one way this pattern is manifested. Suppose an individual grows up in a religious household, takes upon themselves the religious identification of their parents, and is a regular participant in the activities of their parents' religious group throughout their childhood.  As they advance through adulthood, their interest in religion declines.  Although they continue to maintain their identification with the same religious group. they rarely participate in church activities.  That is, they originally inherited the "belonging" and "behaving" of their parents as a child but now have an adult have only retained the "belonging."

Why would this pattern come to realization?  Some simple cost-benefit analysis of an example can provide a clue.

First consider the affiliation decision.  There are probably some benefits to an individual to retaining their religious affiliation, while there is little benefit to switching.  By keeping their identification, they keep their parents happy to an extent.  They can also attend church with their parents on major holidays, thereby maintaining some family cohesion.  But it is also the case that keeping the religious identification does not involve any costly action.  Although it will differ across individuals, retaining their identification can involve as little as periodic verbal acknowledgement of their affiliation in conversation.  So even if there are relatively few benefits for retaining the affiliation, having a little cost to retaining the affiliation means that a person can retain their inherited affiliation for a long period of time without much pressure to change.

The church-attendance decision is quite different.  Attending in any given week involves clear costs because the time spent at church can be spent on so many other activities -- sleeping, exercising, studying, earning money, practicing a hobby, enjoying time with friends, streaming a movie online, and so on.  Time-allocation decisions are frequent and regular with pretty clear costs.  So even though the decision to attend any particular week might seem to be a less significant decision than the decision of one's religious affiliation, the fact that there are clear and obvious costs to attending church means that the decline in religious participation may occur more steadily with a decline in religious demand and long before a change -- if any -- in religious affiliation.

This simple analysis illustrates one of the reasons why religiosity is complex, namely, that the costs and benefits of different types of religiosity can change in different ways, and this can result in different trends in those different types of religiosity even for the same individual.

Wednesday, September 28, 2022

The U.S. Catholic Church's Internal Self-evaluation

In October 2021, Pope Francis asked the worldwide membership of the Catholic Church to reflect on the church, its mission, and their membership.  As part of a two-year "Synod of Synodality" (you can see the Vatican's web site for the Synod here), leaders of local congregations (parishes) and local collections of congregations (dioceses) were to engage in dialogues with their members to gather information about their members' experiences and perspectives.  In the U.S., the local reports from this process were then to be sent to the national U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops who would then create a summary for Catholicism as a whole in the U.S.  This summary -- called the National Synthesis -- was completed and sent to the Vatican in August 2022 and can be found here in pdf format.

This document provides an excellent look at the key issues and concerns of American Catholics who remain the largest religious denomination in the U.S.  So this study is worth a look.  It intends to reflect contributions from about 700,000 persons, so this was a large collective effort.

Several key issues are identified in the report as being of extreme importance to the study participants, and I will mention just a few of them.

The first issue mentioned is the sexual abuse within the Church.  The report states: "The sin and crime of sexual abuse has eroded not only trust in the hierarchy and the moral integrity of the Church, but also created a culture of fear that keeps people from entering into relationship with one another and thus from experiencing the sense of belonging and connections for which they yearn" (p. 5).

Another issue was "to be a more welcoming Church where all members of the People of God can find accompaniment on the journey. ...  People want the Church to be a home for the wounded and broken, not an institution for the perfect" (p. 7).  LGTBQ+, divorced, and those with special needs (e.g., deaf) members were identified as particularly in need of this welcoming, and there was a desire for women to have more leadership roles.

A third issue, called "co-responsibility" in the report (p. 11), is to find a better balance of the religious work between the clergy (the appointed religious leaders) and the laity (the member volunteers).  There was an expression that the laity can do more than they have been doing.

Yet other issues are mentioned so you can see the report for more details.  Of course, this report reflects the concerns of American Catholics who participated, and the concerns of Catholics in other countries can and will differ.  Nonetheless, a lesson for our class is that religious groups -- even ones as old and established as the Catholic Church -- must continue to adapt and innovate when confronting changing circumstances and challenges.  Only by doing this can they keep up in an ever changing religious marketplace.

Friday, September 16, 2022

The Future of American Religion

The Pew Research Center published a new report titled Modeling the Future of Religion in America (full pdf here).  The main idea is to make projections of religious affiliation rates going forward fifty years.  Making projections is a tricky sort of business because it is all about identifying which of the current trends will continue, which will not, and what not-yet-experienced trends may occur.

This report proceed by considering a few different levels of switching out of Christianity.  With no switching, Christianity remains the majority religious tradition by affiliation in 2070, but with other switching scenarios, Christianity loses its majority status by 2070.

The report also discusses some of the nuts and bolts underlying the projections.  For example, the projections need to make various assumptions about not just rates of religious disaffiliation, but also about fertility, mortality, migration, and intergenerational religious transmission.

With so many moving parts, it is impossible to get everything correct, but making a perfect projection is too high of a standard.  What this report can do -- and does pretty well in my opinion -- is provide a limited number of plausible future scenarios.

Tuesday, February 15, 2022

Students' Beliefs and Academic Success

This article by Ilana Horowitz at Religion News Service reports on interesting findings on the relationship between religiosity and academic success.  Religiously devout American students get higher grades and are more likely to graduate from college, on average, than students who are much less religious, but they also attend less selective colleges.  Read the article to see the explanation, and to see what the research reveals about atheist students.

The Nuns of TikTok

The Daughters of St. Paul have created a splash on TikTok, getting millions of views for their videos.  They also got some attention in the latest issue of the Economist Magazine (gated).

Their videos reveal the creative and humorous sides to these nuns from outside of Boston -- especially Sister Orianne Pietra Rene and Sister Danielle Lussier.  As explained in that Economist article, the videos have also created opportunities for them to share their beliefs and develop new friendships.  Even if these videos were not intended to serve a missionary purpose, they still do, which goes to show you that publicity can take many forms.  And different forms allow the nuns to reach different people.

Friday, February 4, 2022

The Benefits and Costs of Streaming Church Services

The COVID pandemic has affected social interactions in many ways, and this is also true for religious interactions.  One of the biggest changes for churches is is that many congregations began live streaming their church services online.  Some did this because large worship services were temporarily prohibited by law, while others did it to enable members with health concerns who would not attend in person to watch remotely, or both.

As COVID infection rates have continued to fluctuate, congregations that started live streaming during the pandemic must decide whether or not to continue streaming their services.  But as with any type of activity, the streaming of church services has benefits and costs.  Let us consider some of these here.

Benefits:

  1. Streaming allows people who would not participate in person to participate remotely.  Streaming thus allows those people to maintain their religious capital -- or to prevent it from depreciating as rapidly as it would if they did not participate at all.  This is the most important reason to stream and is the main motivation for beginning to stream during the pandemic.  Some members might be especially served by streaming services, including those who are out of town and those whose health prevents them from attending in person.
  2. Streaming allows the congregation to more easily reach and recruit new members.  Attending a congregation for the first time can be a scary experience.  When a person is invites you to attend church you have not previously attended, you might hesitate to go because you are unsure of what the experience will be like.  Watching a service remotely entails a much lower cost and risk because you can easily stop the stream or watch anonymously.  Streaming the service thus allows potential recruits an easier entry into the congregation.  Some people might be too afraid to go in person but be willing to watch remotely, and maybe they will come in person once they determine that they like the congregation. 
  3. Streamed services can be recorded, thereby allowing some people to have a form of engagement with a church service that they missed synchronously.  As with 1 and 2 above, the ability to watch a recorded services enable people to reinforce their religious capital when they might not have been able to do so otherwise.

Costs:

  1. Some people who would attend in person if there was no remote option might switch to remote attendance rather than attend in person.  If this happens, then the lower in-person attendance can reduce the vitality of the in-person meetings.  It also means that those who switch to remote viewing will have fewer chances to develop friendship and other ties at church services, thereby causing their religious capital to be lower than it would be without the remote option.  Worshipping together and fellowshipping each other are two of the main benefits of in-person church attendance, and these are missed when people switch from in-person participation to remote viewing.  Lower in-person participation can thus bring a lower quality of collective religious production.
  2. Some equipment and software may need to be purchased, and a volunteer will need to run the live stream.  The technical requirements for streaming a church service are not that large.  A smart phone and a Zoom account can be enough to do a simple live stream, and a tripod and good microphone can improve the quality. More sophisticated set-ups with multiple audio feeds and viewer participation are also possible, and a volunteer will be needed to run the live stream.  Note that many of these technical costs are set-up costs that are paid when first beginning the live streams and not thereafter.  The ongoing costs of continuing to live stream are fairly low.

The size of these benefits and costs will differ across congregations.  A congregation that places a high value on in-person participation will be less comfortable with an easy remote option that creates an added incentive for members to skip church because of the convenience of remote viewing.  Another congregation that values a low cost of initial participation for potential new members will like having the remote option for new recruits.  There might also be innovations in how to grant access to the live stream or the recordings that try to balance different desires.  For example, a congregation can limit access to its live stream, e.g., limit to only those who are unable to attend in person due to health.  By limiting the remote access, the in-person participation is promoted while still making a remote option available for some of the members.

A key point to take away from this discussion is that we should expect to see wide variation across congregations in how streaming is used going forward.  Some will continue their live streams while others will stop them, and among those that continue there will be variation in how open or restricted the access is to those live streams.

Monday, September 21, 2020

American Teenagers' Religiosity

 The Pew Forum recently released a study on the religiosity of American teenagers, see here.

Not surprisingly, most teenagers report having the same religious affiliation as their parents, but there is some variation across denominations.  Children of evangelical Protestant and Roman Catholic parents are much more likely to share their parents' affiliation than children of mainline Protestant parents.  Children of unaffiliated parents are also very likely to be unaffiliated.  The church attendance of children also matches that of their parents.  When asked about religious beliefs and values, more differences are found.

These findings are not too surprising as we that understand many parents will make the religious affiliation and attendance decisions for their children.  Yet they still do provide insight into the religious landscape.

Tuesday, October 2, 2018

Jewish Summer Camp

How do you best transmit your religious values to your children?  According to this Religion News Service article, sending your children to a Jewish summer camp might be one of the best ways to transmit Reform Jewish values.  Specifically, a survey conducted by the Reform Jewish movement:
...found that those who participated in overnight summer camps or immersive weekend-long getaways through the Reform youth movement were far more likely to be engaged in Jewish life in college and beyond and more committed to “doing good.”
Read the article and think about how attending a summer camp or weekend getaway would help in the transmission of religious values.  Do you believe the conclusion that attending a summer camp contributes to the transmission of values?

Note that the survey finds a statistical correlation.  It might be that the face-value interpretation -- namely, that attending a Jewish summer camp contributes to the transmission of Jewish values -- is correct. Yet, there is a second interpretation.  It might instead be that individuals who attend Jewish camps are not your average Reform Jews but are already committed to Jewish values.  So the correlation found in the study might merely reflect the alternative possibility that committed Jews are more likely to attend a Jewish summer camp, and that attending the camp does not actually enhance commitment.

Which interpretation do you think is correct?  Could both be true to a degree?

Friday, August 31, 2018

Pew's New Religious Typology

The Pew Forum has released a new report, The Religious Typology: A New Way to Categorize Americans by Religion (pdf here), that classifies Americans into three categories:  highly religious, somewhat religious, and non-religious.  Those categories are further broken down as shown in this table into the seven key groups that comprise the typology.



Broad categories
The seven groups
Description
Highly religious
Sunday Stalwarts
Traditional, actively involved in congregation.
God-and-country Believers
Less active at church, socially and politically conservative, anti-immigrant
Diversely Devout
Traditional plus belief in psychics, reincarnation, and spiritual energy
Somewhat religious
Relaxed Religious
Religion important personally but not necessary to be moral, not engaged in traditional practices
Spiritually Awake
Believe in heaven, hell, and New Age belief, but do not engage in traditional practices
Non-religious
Religion Resisters
Believe organized religious more bad than good, politically liberal and Democratic
Solidly Secular
Virtually no religious beliefs, reject New Age beliefs


Because the seven groups are constructed based on religious behaviors and beliefs, they will cut across the denominational identities often used to classify individuals.  For example, 13% of the Sunday Stalwarts are Catholic, but 25% of the Relaxed Religious are Catholic, as are 9% of the Religious Resisters.  Also, the Sunday Stalwart group includes individuals from non-Christian faiths (even though the do not technically worship on Sunday).

A primary merit of this seven-group classification is that it highlights some of the diversity in the American religious marketplace.  The challenge, of course, is to find the right number of groups.  To many and the classifications become meaningless, but too few and the classifications are also meaningless.  For this report, Pew used a statistical procedure called cluster analysis to let the data reveal what appear to be statistically coherent subgroupings in the data.  Doing this does involve making assumptions, such as what are the crucial data to include in the analysis.  Here, Pew included data from 16 particular survey questions about religious practices and broad beliefs.

Of course, this procedure ignores other forms of diversity, such as more particular theological beliefs, that are not captured in those 16 questions.  But this is the nature of social scientific inquiry:  some data are privileged over others, wisdom and care should be used in deciding on what is privileged;  and honesty about the pros and cons  and strengths and weaknesses of the analysis and results should be maintained.

Thursday, April 19, 2018

Grave Sucking

According to this article, it has also been called "grave soaking" or "mantle grabbing."  The idea is to lay prostrate on the surface above the grave of a holy person and soak up the spiritual power of that person as it leaks from that person's buried body.

The title of the article refers to this practice as "crazy," and its conclusion seems to reveal that the author is highly skeptical of the merits of the practice.  Yet, it is not obvious to me that practice is crazier than other religious practices such as praying, giving offerings, wearing religious tokens, or participating in other religious rites.  Grave sucking is less common that those other practices to be sure, but because a practice is less common or outside traditional practice does not imply that it is necessarily less valid.

However, perhaps the issue of credibility may be more subtle?  Do you think that a practice may be perceived as less credible because it is less common?  That is, is there some possible logical connection between the frequency with which a religious practice is undertaken and its credibility and efficacy?

Wednesday, October 26, 2016

Increase in Percent of Americans Raised in Inter-faith Homes

The Pew Research Center has just released the results of a study on inter-faith homes here:

[T]he number of Americans raised in interfaith homes appears to be growing. Fully one-quarter of young adults in the Millennial generation (27%) say they were raised in a religiously mixed family. Fewer Generation Xers (20%), Baby Boomers (19%) and adults from the Silent and Greatest generations (13%) say they were raised in such a household.


A number of other findings are also reported, such as those from an inter-faith home are much more likely to adopt the mother's religious affiliation than the father's.

Wednesday, August 24, 2016

Choosing a New Place to Worship

The Pew Forum recently reported survey results from asking Americans about the factors that influence a change in place of worship.  See the overview here.  Not surprisingly, moving residences figures prominently in why people change the place of worship.

But when searching, the most commonly cited factor in choosing the new place of worship is quality of service.  Style of service is the third most cited factor.  Both of these relate to what we in our class call the ideal strictness of the individual.  Having friends or family in the congregation is also important, which matches the notion of religious capital.

Tuesday, June 21, 2016

Pascal's Wager

Last week's Research on Religion podcast has an interview with philosopher Michael Rota on Taking Pascal's Wager.  He tackles the rationality of choosing a religious life, including the philosophical challenges to choosing a religious life.

Tuesday, January 26, 2016

The Pope's Twitter Account Revisited

Back in December 2012, Pope Benedict XVI was the first pope to open a Twitter account.  See my original post on this here.

Pope Francis, not to be outdone, also created a Twitter account.  Take a look at it here;  scroll down and look at his last posts of the last few months.  What do you notice?  Why would Pope Francis take the time out of his busy schedule to maintain an active Twitter account?  Can you use our economic approach to religion to think meaningfully about the pope's Twitter usage?  Does the notion of religious capital provide any insight?

(OK, it is possible that one of the pope's assistants does the actual posting with some input from the pope, but let us just assume that the pope is actually choosing the content).